Service-Learning in Design and Planning
Educating at the Boundaries
Tom Angotti,
Keith Bartholomew,
Amanda M. Beer,
Peter Butler,
Linda Corkery,
Pat Crawford,
Cheryl Doble,
Susan Erickson,
Susan C. Harris,
Sally Harrison, AIA,
Paula Horrigan,
Jeffrey Hou,
Clara Irazábal,
Paul Kelsch,
Zenia Kotval,
Laura Lawson,
Mira Locher,
Lynne M. Dearborn,
Patricia Machemer,
V. Paul Poteat,
Ann Quinlan,
Jodi Rios,
Michael Rios,
Joseph Schilling,
Lynda Schneekloth,
Scott Shannon,
Lisa B. Spanierman,
Jack Sullivan,
Daniel Winterbottom
Edited by
Tom Angotti,
Cheryl Doble,
Paula Horrigan
This collection of case studies by design educators critically explores the current practice of service-learning in architecture, landscape design, and urban planning, radically revising the standard protocol for university-initiated design and planning projects in the community. The authors' lively examination of real-life community collaborations forms a pedagogical framework for educators, professionals, and students alike, offering guidelines for a generative and inclusive collaborative design process.
Includes contributions by the leading practitioners of service-learning in the design professions, including Daniel Winterbottom and Michael Rios.
Editors: Tom Angotti is professor of urban affairs and planning at Hunter College, City University of New York, and director of the Hunter College Center for Community Planning and Development. Cheryl Doble is an associate professor in the Department of Landscape Architecture and director of the Center for Community Design Research at SUNY ESF. Paula Horrigan is a professor in the Department of Landscape Architecture at Cornell University and for the past five years has acted as faculty chair of Cornell's Faculty Fellow-in-Service Governance Board.
Advance Praise:
"An impressive collection on an important topic. Crossing design and planning, this engaging volume brings together a number of different approaches to service-learning—theoretically, by field, and in the scale of the activities in space and time. This makes it useful and important reading for both those starting off in the field of community-based education and old hands interested in critically reflecting on their past practice."
— Ann Forsyth, Professor of City and Regional Planning, Cornell University
"This collection has its roots in the ideas of education theorists such as Dewey, Bruner, and Freire, all of whom advocate for the importance of experiential learning. The authors individually and collectively advance the idea of service-learning to community participation and social action. Consequently, this book not only challenges conventional thinking about education and practice but also illustrates a variety of successful off-the-shelf approaches. Design and planning educators and practitioners will find it to be a valuable companion in support of identifying directions for the future."
— Henry Sanoff, Professor Emeritus of Architecture, ACSA/Alumni Distinguished Professor, North Carolina State University
"An invaluable new resource for faculty engaged in interdisciplinary action research aimed at building more vibrant, sustainable, and just neighborhoods, communities, and regions through inspired physical design."
— Kenneth M. Reardon, Professor and Director of the Graduate Program in City and Regional Planning, University of Memphis
"The time is ripe for advancing a solid service-learning pedagogy in architecture, landscape architecture, and planning. Over several decades of innovation, experimentation, and trial and error, each of these design disciplines has spawned new and critical theory, linking professional work and social change. The wisdom of the twenty-nine leaders in service-learning within this volume provides a collective leap forward that benefits us all—students, teachers, designers, and the general public."
— Bryan Bell, Founder, Design Corps; author, Expanding Architecture: Design as Activism and Good Deeds Good Design: Community Service through Architecture
Details
Title
Service-Learning in Design and Planning
Subtitle
Educating at the Boundaries
Authors
Tom Angotti, Keith Bartholomew, Amanda M. Beer, Peter Butler, Linda Corkery, Pat Crawford, Cheryl Doble, Susan Erickson, Susan C. Harris, Sally Harrison, AIA, Paula Horrigan, Jeffrey Hou, Clara Irazábal, Paul Kelsch, Zenia Kotval, Laura Lawson, Mira Locher, Lynne M. Dearborn, Patricia Machemer, V. Paul Poteat, Ann Quinlan, Jodi Rios, Michael Rios, Joseph Schilling, Lynda Schneekloth, Scott Shannon, Lisa B. Spanierman, Jack Sullivan, Daniel Winterbottom
BISAC Subject Heading
SOC000000 SOCIAL SCIENCE
ARC013000 ARCHITECTURE / Study & Teaching
ARC010000 ARCHITECTURE / Urban & Land Use Planning
Electre Audience Codes France
Professionnels
Universitaire
Audience
05 College/higher education
06 Professional and scholarly
Audience
Undergraduate and graduate programs in architecture, urban design, landscape architecture, urban studies and urban planning, including faculty and students; Professional associations in the above areas (ASLA, AIA, APA)
Title First Published
15 November 2011
Includes
Index; Appendices
Format
Paperback
Nb of pages
320 p. Index . Appendices .
ISBN-10
1-61332-001-9
ISBN-13
978-1-61332-001-3
GTIN13 (EAN13)
9781613320013
Publication Date
10 December 2011
Nb of pages
320
Illustrations
15 Illustrations
Dimensions
6 x 9 in.
List Price
$19.95
Summary
Preface and Acknowledgments
Introduction—At the Boundaries: The Shifting Sites of Service-Learning in Design and Planning
Tom Angotti, Cheryl Doble, and Paula Horrigan
Part One: Beginning to See "the Other"
Editor's Introduction
1. Uncovering the Human Landscape in North Philadelphia
Sally Harrison
2. Reconsidering the Margin: Relationships of Difference and Transformative Education
Jodi Rios
3. Differences Matter: Learning to Design in Partnership with Others
Jeffrey Hou
4. Educating for Multicultural Learning: Revelations from the East St. Louis Design Studio
Laura Lawson, Lisa B. Spanierman, V. Paul Poteat, and Amanda M. Beer
5. People and Place: Communication and Community Development
Keith Bartholomew and Mira Locher
Part Two: Learning to Reflect and Evaluate
Editor's Introduction
6. Transforming Subjectivities: Service that Expands Learning in Urban Planning
Susan C. Harris and Clara Irazábal
7. Operative Sites for Dialogue and Reflection: The Role of Praxis in Service-Learning
Michael Rios
8. Potential and Limits of the PLaCE Program's Design Extension Studio Model
Peter Butler and Susan Erickson
9. Moving from Service-Learning to Professional Practice: ESLARP's Impact on Its Alumni
Lynne M. Dearborn
Part Three: Crossing Borders
Editor's Introduction
10. Easing Boundaries through Placemaking: Sustainable Futures Study Abroad Program
Lynda Schneekloth and Scott Shannon
11. Effecting Change through Humanitarian Design
Daniel Winterbottom
Part Four: Confronting Academic Boundaries
Editor's Introduction
12. From Boundaries to Synergies of Knowledge and Expertise: Using Pedagogy as a Driving Force for Change
Pat Crawford, Zenia Kotval, and Patricia Machemer
13. Integrating Disciplines, Practices, and Perspectives in the Commonwealth Avenue Project
Paul Kelsch and Joseph Schilling
14. Forging Lasting Community Impacts and Linkages through the Capstone Community Design Studio
Jack Sullivan
15. Toward a Scholarship of Engagement: A Model from Australia
Linda Corkery and Ann Quinlan
Endnotes
References
Contributors
Index
Excerpt
Chapter 1
Uncovering the Human Landscape in North Philadelphia
Sally Harrison, Temple University
Every culture proliferates along its margins … Bubbling out of swamps and bogs, a thousand flashes at once scintillate and are extinguished all over the surface of a society. In the official imaginary, they are noted only as exceptions or marginal events … In reality, creation is a disseminated proliferation. It swarms and throbs. A polymorphous carnival infiltrates everywhere… —Michel de Certeau
Introduction
Looking north from the ninth floor studio, my students and I gaze over a gridded landscape that extends for miles until it merges with the horizon. We see a fabric that is regular and monochromatic, dominated by brick row houses and punctuated by the sweep of rail lines, patches of bulky nineteenth century industrial structures and vacant land. In the near middle ground, just beyond the embankment for the trains that connect the university with the center city and suburbs, are two public housing towers. I ask the students to look just to the right of the towers and to the ground. There a spot of brilliant cerulean blue comes into focus.
Tiny in relation to the terrain within our scope of vision, this flash of color—the fragment of a mural—connects us to a specific place that will emerge as the locus of an on-going service-learning project undertaken by Temple University architecture students. The mural is the most visible landmark of the Village of Arts and Humanities, a unique art-based enclave in the Hartranft/Fairhill community only six blocks from the dense and busy urban campus of Temple University.
In spite of being under the gaze of the architecture building, North Philadelphia's neighborhoods have figured little in the mental maps of the students. Mostly the students sustain a generalized concept of the decaying urban context: an undifferentiated, troubling landscape, functioning on the margins of their studio-focused life. But the Village of Arts and Humanities and the community where it is situated has inspired our imagination. A self-built network of parks and gardens woven into the interstices of North Philadelphia's deteriorating residential fabric, the Village asserts that decay and loss open the possibility for beauty and innovation. This particular place and the polymorphous carnival of everyday life that infiltrates it have offered to the students a complex local narrative, and a threshold for learning about design in the contemporary city.
Walking in the City, Seeing, and Connecting
From the architecture school, students now regularly tread a path north to the Village of Arts and Humanities. With this ritual, they craft a continuous spatial bond that connects their experiences of the university and the neighborhood, expanding if not erasing boundaries. Up 12th Street they walk past the newish housing that abuts the campus, and as they approach the city recreation center, they see the basketless hoops and cracked concrete pavement. They pass a stretch of row homes that stand in various states of disrepair across the street from an imposing stone railroad embankment. Through the underpass, they emerge into the open space of Fotteral Square; the two high-rise housing towers we can see from the studio stand at its south. The students cut diagonally across the square.
Turning onto tiny Warnock Street between a prolific vegetable garden and the local bar, the Village of Arts and Humanities unfolds in the ellipses of the residential fabric. First, they see a field of colorful posts against a mural of angels. Facing it, there is a row of abandoned row houses painted white, waiting. Halfway up Warnock is a sign announcing another Community Garden, but it is densely overgrown with honeysuckle, and we can't see inside. Across from it is a well-tended flower garden bounded by a tiled mural. The students proceed up the street—a continuous wall of brick homes, some abandoned, some with people chatting at their stoops—and they pass between two abandoned houses into a tiny walled park, all hardscape with a floor like a mosque, that connects them mid-block to Alder Street. Like Warnock, Alder is small in scale, though better maintained and active; people walk down the middle of the street or move purposefully from building to building.
At its far end, the monumental cerulean blue mural stands, the backdrop of a public park, shady and filled with mosaic sculpture. On a stage at the base of the mural, a group of teenagers are coached in step-dancing routine. Beyond, the bustle of Germantown Avenue can be seen and felt—sunlight and motion, the music from a passing car, the metallic clatter of security gates opening, the acrid smell of blue exhaust from the Number 23 bus. Around the park side of the building, the students step out to the sidewalk; they have reached the official front door of the Village of Arts and Humanities, a ninteenth-century storefront at a bend on Germantown Avenue. The neighborhood commercial street with its variety stores, clothing shops, take-outs, check-cashing establishments stretches north, faltering, uneven, but still gathering and focusing community life.
The Village of Arts and Humanities and Shared Prosperity
The Temple students have joined the scores of neighborhood residents, artists, and activists who have participated in the building of the Village since it started as a single public art project over two decades ago. The Ile Ife Park was built over three summers by the artist Lily Yeh in several vacant lots with the help of neighborhood children, and framed by a monumental mural on the three-story blank party wall of 2544 Germantown Avenue. The Village evolved organically, reaching into and transforming the fragmented physical space of the neighborhood. Seventeen parks and gardens were constructed for public use, and six abandoned buildings on Alder Street and the building on Germantown Avenue were rehabilitated to house after-school arts programs and workshops. Committed to the belief that creative engagement in place can change lives, Yeh engaged neighborhood residents in the land transformation process. Two recovering drug addicts with natural artistic gifts became her chief support. Together, their presence in the neighborhood as productive, skilled craftsmen and mentors tacitly communicated that renewal can be found in even the most degraded conditions.
Reviews
Press Reviews
Service-Learning in Design and Planning
International Planning Studies
Jul 12, 2012
This is a book primarily for educators of planners rather than students. Planners and others outside the academy who are already partners in service-learning, or are contemplating it, will also find much of interest. The book consists of 16 chapters, including an introduction. The 15 substantive chapters are mostly case studies, and even those which are not case studies are still based on direct experience of service-learning. Only one relates to teaching in a university outside the USA, but to put it in a way which might well please the editors, the experiences and discussions described in the other chapters certainly cross national boundaries. The experiences drawn upon involve teaching in landscape design and architecture, as well as planning, but again that is not a barrier to lessons being learned by those involved solely in planning education. The amount of detail offered about the service-learning experiences on which authors draw varies a great deal. In some chapters we are given blow-by-blow accounts of what happened and why, along with student and other voices; in others, we are given summaries of the service-learning, and the authorial judgement has to be taken pretty much on trust. Generally, this does not matter — these different kinds of accounts often have different things to teach us, and do so in appropriately different ways.
The book's sub-title reminds us why service-learning is so exciting, yet can be difficult to achieve. By definition, it involves crossing the boundary between the university and the outside world; and in practice it usually involves many other meetings at boundaries too. For example, real world issues always spill over academic and professional boundaries, so service-learning must address cross-disciplinarity. Typically, students find themselves working in communities and neighbourhoods quite unlike those in which they were brought up, so boundaries of race and class, in particular, are likely to be implicated in service-learning. If the service-learning is in a different country from the university — usually a poorer one — then the socio-economic boundaries to be crossed are even more complex. The book is based on the belief that acknowledging and addressing these boundaries is central to the value of service-learning, not incidental distractions. On this view, service-learning is as much about the development of all those involved (with particular attention paid to the student, naturally) towards being rounded, humane, mature, and educated, people, with all these elements being mutually supportive. This is a process that is never complete, of course, but one in which a good education at any level is thought by some to play a vital role. The contributors to the book do not appear to share any theoretical or philosophical positions which go beyond the rather general educational orientation described above. In some chapters there are references to Freire (though with slightly different interpretations of the implications of his thought); in others, references to Schon; and, in many, references to a variety of other influences. This does no matter over-much: there are papers in many journals, including planning journals, which explore how service-learning might be understood within particular political and pedagogical theories. What this book offers is the stimulation one gets from the company of a group of committed, experienced and able people who do the same job as you: you may not approach the job in quite the same way, or have exactly the same aims, but it is a major surprise if you do not come away with some new ideas, and renewed enthusiasm, after engaging with them.
The book is organized into four sections, with each ostensibly focused around a particular aspect of border-meetings and crossings in service-learning. The titles of these sections convey pretty well what these aspects are: 'Beginning to see "the Other"', 'Crossing Borders' (international service-learning), 'Confronting Academic Boundaries', and 'Learning to Reflect and Evaluate’. Each section is conscientiously introduced by the editors, but this reader, at least, could see no strong connection between chapters in any given section. Perhaps this should not surprise us — what emerges from the book is that most effective service-learning has certain key elements, and consequently these tend to get at least some mention in almost every chapter. The experiences recounted in this book suggest that the foundations of effective service-learning are:
-an awareness, from the outset, that service-learning takes place within a social context which is shot through with socially-significant boundaries and imbalances of power;
-service-learning can, in its modest way, challenge these, but only if they are first acknowledged and understood;
-working with organizations and individuals who are deeply-rooted in the neighbourhoods where the service-learning will happen;
-working as mutually respectful partners with such organizations, ideally over a considerable period of time;
-good planning of all aspects of the service-learning activity, married with a willingness to respond to new opportunities as they arise ‘in the field’;
-systematic reflection, by all involved (not simply students) on what they are doing, what they are learning (in the broadest sense) and how the socio-political dynamics are evolving. Despite having a section supposedly devoted to it, this book does not really discuss reflection in any depth. But the consensus among most who write about the topic, outside this book, is that reflective learning and practice needs a supportive environment, so creating that must be foundational in service-learning.
Of course, there are very many more details which contribute to success, but these appear to be the major building blocks. What is striking about them is that social relations (interpersonal, inter-group, inter-organizational), rather than training in this or that technique, are at their heart. And social relations need nurturing, can be messy, can be time consuming. Often, good social relations, in an educational context, have no ‘output’ other than better balanced, more mature, learners — in a word, better people. For this reason, among others, service-learning can sometimes run against the grain of contemporary education with its trends towards the Taylorization of teaching and learning, and the valorization of research and publication over teaching. As more than one chapter notes, devoting time and effort to service-learning is not the most efficient route to academic advancement. Fortunately, many university teachers persist; this book will reassure them that they are in good company, as they strive to provide an humane and rounded education for planners and designers.
-
Huw Thomas, School of City and Regional Planning, Cardiff University
Service-Learning in Design and Planning
The Midwest Book Review
Apr 10, 2012
More people understanding how it all works means more people can help bring it all together.
Service-Learning in Design and Planning: Educating at the Boundaries seeks to expand the knowledge of urban planning and architecture within communities, studying elements from around the world and how they can be applied locally and lead to a more inclusive plan for the communities of tomorrow.
Service-Learning in Design and Planning is an informative and much recommended read for those who want to understand the importance of a communities wishes in preparing for its future.
Service-Learning in Design and Planning
Journal of Global Citizenship & Equity Education
This book makes a valuable contribution to the field by discussing and showcasing a number of service-learning programs and models that an academic could use in developing their own programs and partnerships. It is an exciting addition to the field of service-learning and a very great resource for any academic developing a service-learning program as part of their curriculum. Students, researchers and community partners in the field of service-learning will find the information very useful.
-
Eva Aboagye
Service-Learning in Design and Planning
Folio Magazine
This collection of case studies critically explores the current practice of community-engaged learning in architecture, landscape design, and urban planning and forms a pedagogical framework for design educators.
-
Spring 2012
Related Resources
On Friday, April 13, 2012, editors Tom Angotti and Paula Horrigan and chapter authors Sally Harrison and Clara Irazábal sat down with the Van Alen Institute to discuss the role of community-based projects in design education by exploring some of the case studies in
Service-Learning in Design and Planning: Educating at the Boundaries.
Apr 20, 2012